Publisher: Victory Point Games
Designer: John Welch
Artist: Tim Allen
Year: 2011
Players: Solitaire (although noted two or more players as well)
Ages: 10+
Playing Time: 55 Minutes at Peking (oh, those VPG guys are such kidders!)
Category: Solitaire States of Siege wargame
MSRP: $22.95
It’s been a while since we tackled a Victory Point Game release and I’m happy to say the latest title to hit the table is from our friend John Welch. Not to jump too far off topic, but one of the reasons we enjoy playing games from VPG isn’t only because we think the vast majority of their titles are great but also because of the really good people behind the scenes at “The Little Company that Could.” There are a lot of lousy games produced by really great people and there are plenty of excellent games designed by folks who wouldn’t pee on you if you were on fire.
I’m happy to say that Victory Point Games is one of those companies out where really great people are making really good games. This isn’t to say that they are alone in this fact – we deal with a lot of companies who are wonderful – yet there are producers we will not deal with nor mention their games any longer because they aren’t very nice or run you around at conventions promising interviews and continue to blow you off. But that’s a story for another day as I’m talking about cool people, and John Welch is defiantly one of the good guys in the hobby.
VPG likes to bring us, from time to time, games that focus on some of the more obscure moments in history. Granted, the Boxer Rebellion certainly isn’t as obscure a topic as the Aaron Burr conspiracy (as dealt with in Hero of Weehawken) but it isn’t on the top of many people’s minds either. For those unfamiliar with the Boxer Uprising, as it is also known, suffice to say that in the waning years of the 19th century and the very beginning of the 20th many Chinese weren’t all too happy with the influx of foreigners making an impression on their way of life.
The Society of Righteous and Harmonious Fists was a nationalist movement of those who wanted to drive the “foreign devils” out of China. Otherwise known as The Boxers, these people felt that too much influence was being meted out by these outsiders and they did not want to see a Westernization of their homeland nor be a victim of imperialist aims. Add in the fact The Boxers hated missionaries spreading Christianity throughout the land and it’s plain to see that things were going to boil over at some point.
In June 1900 in Peking (modern day Beijing), Boxer fighters threatened all foreigners and forced them to seek refuge in the Legation Quarter. In response, the initially hesitant Empress Dowager Cixi, urged by the conservatives of the Imperial Court, supported the Boxers and declared war on foreign powers. With this, all hell broke loose across China as foreigners and Christians (especially Chinese Christians) were massacred. Diplomats, foreign civilians and soldiers, and Chinese Christians moved into the Legation Quarter of the city. The legations – United Kingdom, France, Germany, Italy, Austria-Hungary, Spain, Belgium, the Netherlands, the US, Russia and Japan – were ordered to leave the Chinese mainland but following the murder of German envoy Klemens Freiherr von Ketteler, in an open street, the legations decided to defy the Empress’s order. At that point, the Imperial Army of China and the Boxers laid siege.
The only hope in breaking the siege, and saving the legations, was more than a hundred miles away – a relief force known as the Eight-Nation Alliance under the command of British Lieutenant-General Alfred Gaselee.
As usual, the components are fairly typical of recent Victory Point releases. As I’ve mentioned previously, it looks like VPG has raised their game a bit in the sharpness of the graphics as of late and Tim Allen has once again done a fine job. Keep Up the Fire! is small enough to take with you on the go as well, so you can pop it out and game just about anywhere you find yourself.
Of no surprise should be the set of cards which drives all the game action as this is one of the main components of a SoS title. Not only do the cards provide the actions available to the player but also provide additional historical info to provide for a narrative flow. Once again I will provide my two cents and recommend sleeving the cards for ease of play.
You recall I mentioned you’re in charge of not only the legations in Peking but also the rescue force making its way to the city. With this you’ll find that the action cards provide what commands can be used for the forces inside Peking followed by what’s available to the relief column.
In the Legation Phase you’ll randomly place Chinese forces in the outskirts of Peking. At this point the player will attempt to destroy these forces (no easy feat) as the Chinese Army and Boxers advance on the Legation Quarter. All the while you’ll see the strength of your defenders whittled away while the attackers just keep coming. It’s best to do all you can to knock out the enemy from long range as hand to hand fighting is just as devastating for the defender as it is the attacker.
In the Relief Column Phase you’ll look to build up the column and face assaults from the natives as you try to make your way to Peking. It’s important to note that logistics come into play as you can’t just make a mad dash for the city but need to prepare and bolster your force.
As in all States of Siege titles, there’s always a lot more that needs to be done than you’ll have actions available to you. The luck of a single die roll can be crucial and can turn what is shaping up to be a victory into a devastating defeat. There are more ways to lose the game than to win as holding out until the relief force arrives is your only path to victory while allowing the Chinese to reach Fort Hallady (inside the Legation Quarter), having your forces in Peking eliminated, or not getting the column to Peking are all instant losses.
I do like Keep Up the Fire! but there are a couple of minor issues I have with the game:
First, and this is very minor, is the fact that it’s mentioned the game can be played by more than one person. In this scenario one player commands the defense inside Peking while the other commands the relief column. I have to be honest and say that I can’t imagine playing with any of my friends simply because there just isn’t enough to make controlling one of the two forces interesting. In other words, as a solo venture the game works but I think it would be a snorefest for two or more players.
Second, the difficulty of getting the relief column to Peking is pretty skewed. As in it isn’t very historically accurate. Obviously this is a game and it would be much less of a challenge if Gaselee’s troops were able to reach Peking with ease. Yet, historically that was the case as the Chinese Army and Boxers put up very little resistance that wasn’t easily pushed aside. The term “a hot knife through butter” comes to mind.
I understand the relief column aspect of the design brings a new wrinkle, as opposed to just having the Peking defenders hold out for “X number of turns, but there’s just something about it that doesn’t quite ring true. This isn’t a huge issue since I believe the playability of the design is bolstered by the mechanic – it’s a better play even if the history suffers a little.
In the end, I like Keep Up the Fire! and feel it’s a very worthy addition to the States of Siege line. I can’t say it’s the best in the series (that’s a tight race between Dawn of the Zeds and We Must Tell the Emperor) but it certainly is worth picking up. The theme is interesting, it plays well, and it has loads of tension to keep you coming back for more.
John Welch’s mom should be proud!
- Mystic Punks RPG Enters Final Hours on Kickstarter - Apr 17, 2024
- MUST You Support Your Local Game Store? – The Gaming Gang Dispatch #1044 - Apr 17, 2024
- The Achtung! Cthulhu 2d20 Starter Set is Now Available in PDF - Apr 17, 2024
2 Comments
Jeff – thanks so much for reviewing Keep Up the Fire! and your kind words about me really made my day. I hate to sound like a history teacher but since it is my day job, I feel duty bound to address the wonkiness. The first two relief columns that attempted to break the siege at Peking were soundly defeated by the Chinese and were forced back to the coast. In fact only some truly miraculous finds (like a fully stocked but unknown arsenal – a real life lucky dice roll if there ever was one), saved the relief force from complete annihilation. It would take two months and a ten-fold increase in the combat strength of the Eight-Nation Army to complete the three week ‘dash’ to Peking and the liberation of the Legations there. That’s what the mechanics of the game are designed to recreate…not just to drive the player crazy…although that can be fun too 😉 That said, I agree that it is primarily a solitaire game like the rest in the line.
Thanks again and my Mom says “Hello”
I liked your review and for journalistic honesty, I do have a playtesting credit with this game. At first, I didn’t think it was that hard for the expeditionary force to get to Peking. While I like John history is history and I checked several sources and… John is a good historian and history teacher. If you get two people play it as a joint command, share in the decison making and allocate the blame accordingly. It is a hard game to win and it does produce a sense of desperation and hopelessness at times until you get the lucky roll or card. This is a game that starts with the player on a knife edge and keeps him there for the rest of the game. I lost one game on the second turn so attention to details is important. Each part of the game, the seige and expeditionary force takes time to master and then you have to combine the two. After playing this game a few times, you might wish you had been dropped down in Roark’s Drift.