Publisher: Paizo Inc
Authors: Jenny Jarzabski with Joseph Blomquist, Sasha Laranoa Harving, Quinn Murphy, and Isabelle Thorne
Artists: Ridell Apellanes, Sol Devia, Arturo Gutierrez, Kent Hamilton, Kyle Hunter, Ivan Koritarev, Denis Medri, Guilherme Olivieri, Sam Perin, Aurele Pradal, and Jino Rufi
Year: 2022
Genre: Starfinder science fantasy roleplaying adventure path chapter
Pages: 64 pages
MSRP: MSRP $24.99 in softcover or $19.99 in PDF
Nightmare Scenario kicks off moments after the conclusion of The Perfect Storm with the crew of the Primorata unsure of where or when they are. There’s no time to lose, however, as the characters are quickly pulled into a dangerous rescue mission pitting them not only against the gravitational pull of a massive black hole, but a scheming AI, before being called upon by an emissary of the goddess Desna. It’s a fun, varied adventure that leads characters on a series of interlocking quests to do good before thrusting them right back into the fight.
Nightmare Scenario offers a nice blend of challenges for characters, ranging from social interactions to hacking to a photo safari and, of course, combat. No matter the makeup of a given group of player characters, everyone has the opportunity to shine and even, possibly, save the day. Fans of Mr. Rogers’ timeless “Look for the helpers” will no doubt enjoy this scenario as it allows player characters to do measurable good in the wake of absolute chaos. For some, it will make the scenario’s unavoidable deaths all the more painful — for all the good characters can do, there will inevitably some lives they can’t save.
The additional information on the Church of Densa and the Cynosure highlights the vibrancy of the world and offers GMs plenty of new adventure hooks, potential drop-in encounters, 
The art is wonderful with the full page pieces truly giving a sense of scale and atmosphere. Cynosure feels truly magical and its evident how closely its tied to Desna herself. There’s something truly haunting about the sight of the Final Horizon, an enormous floating gothic cathedral and monastery, drifting towards its final horizon in the opening piece and the Curiosity’s tiny lifeboat feels as vulnerable as it is.
While Nightmare Scenario offers plenty of emotional payoff, its final chase somewhat blunts the horrific reveal that immediately precedes it, which in the grand scheme of things, is a minor complaint; in any scenario, some beats have to be allowed to hit harder than others and it’s clear that the other major death in the scenario is undoubtedly given the time to register.
Fans of The Perfect Storm Adventure Path will no doubt be thrilled to return to their characters and take up the fight one more, while those jumping in with a modified start will quickly be drawn into the struggle. Nightmare Scenario offers a fun and interesting set of challenges and a nice reminder that heroic deeds come in many forms.
Sami, Jeff. Thank you! Great review as always! As a GM looking for the next “best-thing” to run, it’s always hard to find the right kind of module or story to adapt to my gang. And also, very hard to find good reviews! Sami, your reviews are amazing. I walk away having a clear idea of how the adventure would run and also, if the elements I’m looking for in a module, are there. You manage to share a concise and rich picture of the emotional experience of this adventure in just a few precious words. Just what I was looking for. Always looking forward to reading your next review!