Of course I’m not talking about some innocent PayPal “donate” button on a website or a link to make your online gaming purchases through a retailer whereas your favorite reviewers get a bit of commission from that retailer toward free games. Both of those avenues for a trickle of revenue, along with Google Adsense, normally are what you’ll run across on a gaming site. None of that is very intrusive to the visitor and these are things you’ve been seeing for years.
Running a website isn’t free (unless you’re simply being hosted on WordPress or Blogger – then it is!) and we all know that getting games isn’t free (unless you’re receiving review copies – then it is!) or at least in the real sense of what comes at a price. I’ll be honest by saying even with the funds required to maintain a website and podcast the cost is rather low if you compare it to many other pursuits – hanging out in a bar chasing skirts immediately comes to mind – but the time investment can be a killer. Therein lays two questions that anyone involved in covering the gaming scene has to ask themselves: What is my time worth and why am I doing this in the first place?
Those are two questions I can’t answer for anyone else out there but Elliott and I. The short answer for us is that TGG got started because we believed we could bring something a bit different to the table due to our personalities and combined decades of gaming experiences. We both had a little free time between the two of us so we felt it would be a nice way to invest our time. The longer answer is that I had some experience running websites and recording podcasts while, at the same time, Elliott was getting his kids more and more involved in the hobby so we thought this would be a great way for the two of us to really stay in touch while 1800 miles or so apart. Our thoughts at the time, and to this day, had nothing to do with making money from the endeavor. The Gaming Gang was launched as a lark more than anything else. That’s not to say that our initial approach wasn’t serious or professional but we thought all in all if we got to the point where maybe a hundred people a day showed up we’d be ecstatic.
Which brings me to my somewhat of a rant.
I find it disturbing that there are those in the “gaming media” who seem to think covering games is a sort of get rich quick scheme somehow. That’s bad enough in itself, I suppose, but wouldn’t have led me to write this if we were only talking about paid advertisers or generating revenue from Google ads. Heck, webmasters the world over look to do that! What bothers me to no end though is those who want to pester you into footing their bill, usually under the guise of a charitable contribution.
What really got me rolling on this was the announcement that The Spiel had launched a Kickstarter campaign to finance a trip to this year’s Essen. I’ll be upfront and say that I’ve never been a fan of The Spiel for a multitude of reasons: I find the show to be rather bland, not to mention that I can’t tell one host’s voice from the other nor do I believe either comes across as very knowledgeable outside of shilling what is one “awesome” game after another. Add to the fact neither host seems to have any life until they go into one of their many pledge drives or begin to carry on about what their charity has been up to – always followed by yet another plea for donations; I’ve experienced fewer program interruptions during a PBS pledge drive than in a single episode of The Spiel.
Yet, The Spiel is a popular show and I don’t begrudge them that. I just don’t find them to be my cup of tea in the same vein as our podcast certainly isn’t everyone’s cup of java either. The reality is what irks me is The Spiel wants to have listeners pick up the tab to finance their ambitions, plain and simple. Yes, I understand that they have a non-profit foundation and all but I have to wonder what that’s all about since they have no links to their 501(c)3 bylaws to my knowledge. I’m always a little leery of nonprofits who don’t disclose their mission statement and bylaws to the public. And we won’t even discuss public disclosure of spending…
And now these guys have a Kickstarter project so other people can pay for their trip to Germany? Seriously? I don’t see any mention of The Spiel Foundation anywhere on that. Will those donated funds be counted toward the non-profit? Are these donation dollars also tax exempt? Or are these guys simply pleading for you to shell out for an “awesome” trip for themselves to Essen?
Like many things lately involving Kickstarter, this is something that is going to set a less than desirable precedent; if the Spiel reaches their funding goal that means just about any Tom, Dick, or Mary will take to Kickstarter to roll out projects to send them to conventions worldwide. Or, better yet ask you to fund a start up website, or recording equipment for a podcast, or video cameras, or just about anything under the sun. Hell, why should Elliott and I have to pay for anything relating to The Gaming Gang? Shouldn’t we just ask you to pick up the tab?
Which is what led to this whole thought process in this post. I received a couple of emails asking if Elliott and I were considering launching something on Kickstarter so we could go to Essen. I actually read those emails in horror wondering what we’d ever done to put that thought in someone’s mind. Here we are in our second year and we’ve never asked our visitors for anything more than to spread the word or maybe buy a shirt. We don’t even have Google ads on the site because we want to offer the best value to our advertisers – who, by the way pay for the upkeep of the site and helped us to make the trip to Origins and Gen Con (not to mention other shows in our own backyards) – and someone would think we’d even consider asking the public to finance anything we did?
Like I started the post… A disturbing trend; since other people out there covering games have no qualms about what amounts to public begging, I suppose Elliott and Jeff wouldn’t either?
Long time visitors already know Elliott and I are old school gamers but we’re also old school in a lot of other ways too. You pick up the tab when you go out on a date. You put in a real day’s work for a real day’s pay. You back your friends up no matter what. And you never look for a handout or a free ride. EVER!
It comes down to not only having appreciation and respect for the folks who take time out to come and visit the site or listen to the show, be it once or all the time, but also looking at these same folks as friends – not easy marks to squeeze a few bucks from. For me, it also has to do with having self-respect and doing your best to provide an entertaining momentary distraction from the troubles in our day to day lives. If we can’t pull that off without putting our hand out, then we have no business doing this.
Some would argue we have no business doing this regardless, but suffice to say we’ll never ask you to foot the bill.
- Chivalry & Sorcery Fifth Edition Reviewed - Nov 3, 2024
- Campaign Builder: Castles & Crowns Reviewed - Nov 2, 2024
- The Roleplaying Game of the Planet of the Apes Quickstart | First Look and Page-Through - Nov 1, 2024
Jeff’s Back! There’s the line of think we love so much on the show
I have to say that I give props for saying publicly what alot of gamers think privately. Some of my friends and I used to listen the the spiel but got so turned off by the constant pledge drives and back patting that it became almost sickening to listen to anymore. I heard about the kickstarter thing and first thought it was a joke. But then I heard it was the spiel and knew right there it wasn’t a joke.
BTW we had noticed the spiel always talks about all the charity work they do but they don’t seem to do much more than talk about it. Ever notice that they have almost no pics on their site of them on their charity missions?
“Long time visitors already know Elliott and I are old school gamers but we’re also old school in a lot of other ways too. You pick up the tab when you go out on a date. You put in a real day’s work for a real day’s pay. You back your friends up no matter what. And you never look for a handout or a free ride. EVER!”
This is why Victory Point Games is your proud sponsor!
Right on!!
Alan Emrich
Thanks gang! I just called it as I see it – I’m sure not a popular opinion with some people but I really dislike a lot of the money grubbing that I see some of our “gaming media” brethren engaging in.
And Alan, we’re always proud to have you as a sponsor!
Thought you’d like to know that they’ve raised $6509 so far, or $9 over their goal. Spiel On!
All I can say is P.T. Barnum had it right as far how quickly suckers are produced…
But if you donate $15, you get $2 worth of dice or better yet if you donate $500 you get a “free” game(their choice), maybe it would be something cool like… http://boardgamegeek.com/boardgame/11901/tic-tac-toe
Keep up the good work, love you website and podcast.
More likely the game would be solitaire Tic-tac-toe… 🙂
I agree that it isn’t what Kickstarter should be used for. Rather than funding a project, they really seem to be looking for sponsorship to go to Essen, similar to kids collecting money to fund their senior trip to DC. I wouldn’t do it myself, and I certainly wouldn’t use Kickstarter if for some reason I did.
Wow!
TO top it off not only do they have over $3000 towards the goal, they actually got someone to back them for $1000.00! The reward for said donation? The honor of playing games with them for a day (you pay for transportation to them).
/facepalm
I agree this is a slap in the face of what kickstarter should be for. Eaten By Zombies on kickstarter? Great Idea! Paying for 2 guys to take a dream vacation? Bad Idea!
Hell, you can game with Elliott and I for an entire day and we’d just ask you to buy us a few beers…
I’ll chime in if its ok. I have to agree with you gents. I was surprised to see their pitch on Kickstarter and thought it was ludicrous especially as BGG will be doing the only video worth watching from Essen. Kickstarter should be for unpublished designers trying to catch a break which they might not otherwise get.
Not to be too contrarian but I don’t see what the problem is. I’m also a former Spiel listener although I’m hard pressed to say why I stopped listening to the show. But if their listeners want to contribute, if they feel that they want the Spiel’s take on Essen, more power to ’em. In general I don’t have a problem with podcasters trying to earn something back for their time and effort as long as it is done honestly and up front.
I always welcome contrary opinion here on the site. I certainly have no issue with people wanting to donate to send The Spiel gang to Essen – it’s their money and they can do what they wish. I don’t have a problem with The Spiel constantly looking for cash either – it’s their show and they’re welcome to do as they please with it.
My problem stems from The Spiel putting the project on Kickstarter. I don’t believe that is the place to be looking for funding for this sort of thing. Plus, $6500 is a pretty hefty chunk of change as far as “travel expenses” go for a trip to the show in Germany. I did some research a while back to see if Essen could be in our gameplan and my calculations came out to around to about $3000 for Elliott and I.
I have the impression the guys at The Spiel are pretty much about pocketing cash. I really don’t have an issue with that either as everyone likes to be able to earn some bucks for their hard work. Yet I think the way they present their work as if it is some great humanitarian effort, instead of what in reality is simply a money making venture, is very disingenuous…